TOEFL Speaking: 4.0 in Listen and Repeat, 2.5 in the Interview

This Indonesian speaker earned three perfect Listen and Repeat scores. In the same Chicago test, her final Interview answer scored 0.9/5.

That gap tells us where her TOEFL Speaking practice needs to go. She can reproduce several supplied sentences accurately. When she has to generate and develop her own answers, her output becomes limited, and the final response loses the question's required focus.

The most useful comparison is inside the Interview itself. Her first two answers score 3.4 and 3.5, with complete coverage. The next two drop to 2.1 and 0.9, alongside fewer words and weaker coverage. We can identify those differences without guessing that every part of her English suddenly became worse.

The Chicago results at a glance

Report measureResultWhat it shows
Listen and Repeat4.0/5Several strong repetitions, with accuracy varying by sentence
Take an Interview2.5/5Much less consistent performance when generating answers
Section estimate shown by MSS3.8/6The practice report's section estimate
Average Interview pace69 WPMLimited spoken output across the four response windows
Average Interview word count52 wordsRelatively little material available to develop the answers

Scores and counts are those displayed in the shared My Speaking Score report. Response and task results use a five-point scale. The section estimate uses a six-point scale. These are practice results, not an official TOEFL score report.

The learner's Indonesian background provides context for this case. One test does not establish a pattern for Indonesian speakers generally, and it does not establish a first-language cause for the errors.

Strong repetition does not guarantee a developed Interview answer

In Listen and Repeat, the words and the sentence structure are supplied. The learner has to hear the sentence and reproduce it accurately. In the Interview, she has to decide what to say, choose language, and develop an answer that fulfills the question.

Her repetition results show real strengths. Q1, Q2, and Q6 each scored 5.0/5. Q6 was:

“Do not leave your luggage unattended at any time.”

She reproduced that sentence exactly in the displayed transcript. Yet Q4 and Q5 each scored 2.5/5. On Q4, the transcript omitted “boarding passes and” and changed other wording. On Q5, several words differed from the reference sentence.

That makes repetition accuracy a useful practice target too. But the Interview is the larger weakness in this attempt. Another round of repeating supplied sentences will not, by itself, practise deciding how a business benefits from reduced commuting.

The Interview decline is visible question by question

QuestionScorePaceWordsCoverage
Q8: Living close to work or school3.4/589 WPM67Complete
Q9: Car or public transportation3.5/587 WPM65Complete
Q10: Making commuting enjoyable2.1/552 WPM39Thin
Q11: Effects on businesses0.9/547 WPM35Missing

There are two separate problems here. Across the set, she produces relatively little speech. In the final answer, the content also fails to address the required effects on businesses.

These four results do not tell us whether fatigue, anxiety, topic familiarity, or another factor caused the decline. They do show what needs to change in the responses.

Q8: A relevant answer with room to develop

The first Interview question asks whether it is important to live close to school or work, and why. She takes a position immediately:

“Yes I think it's important to live near our school or work.”

She then explains that she lives two kilometres from her workplace, that the trip takes ten minutes, and that the short commute saves energy. That is a relevant reason supported by a personal detail. Complete coverage makes sense.

Her report also separates delivery from clarity. It labels Fluency as Limited and Intelligibility as Good. The fluency feedback identifies a 2.7-second pause after “workplace” and a 1.3-second pause after “energy.” Those are reported feedback observations, rather than timings measured independently for this article.

The practical target is smoother connected speech with more development. She could explain what arriving with more energy allows her to do at work. That would extend the same idea rather than repeat that a short commute is efficient.

There are language details to refine, such as “arrive at work.” But the opening wording “live near our school or work” is understandable and grammatically possible. A change to “live close to my workplace” would improve personal consistency, not repair an inherently invalid use of “near.” Feedback needs that distinction too.

Q10: A suggestion needs an explanation

Q10 asks for one or two ways to make commuting more enjoyable, with reasons. Her full answer is:

“To make it more enjoyable, I think it must not take too long. If it takes too long then it will be so tiring. I would say 15 minutes are the maximum. Or you can just enjoy the view.”

The answer contains relevant material. A shorter journey can be less tiring, and enjoying the view is a possible way to improve the experience. However, “enjoy the view” arrives at the end with no explanation or example.

The prompt permits one or two suggestions. She does not need a second suggestion to satisfy a fixed two-point formula. She needs to develop a useful suggestion and give a reason for it.

For example: “I would listen to a podcast during the journey because it gives me something interesting to focus on. If traffic is slow, I can still learn something instead of checking the time.” That is a suggested practice alternative, not part of her original response.

Q11: The answer changes who the question is about

The final prompt asks:

“How do you think a severe decline in commuting might affect businesses in positive ways and negative ways? Please give one example of each.”

The important word is businesses. The answer needs a positive business effect, a negative business effect, and an example of each. Here is the learner's full response:

“In a positive way. I think by not commuting then it will save our energy. But in negative way, I think it will reduce our effort and we will not meet our family that often.”

She uses positive and negative labels, but the content focuses on personal energy, effort, and family contact. She does not explain a business benefit or cost, and she supplies no business example. The meaning of “reduce our effort” also remains unclear.

That is the coverage problem. A response can share the topic of commuting while failing to perform the task the question sets.

At 35 words and 47 WPM, the answer also offers little speech. Her report withholds separate detailed evaluations of Fluency, Intelligibility, Language Use, and Organization because there is insufficient speech for that breakdown. We should respect that limit. The 0.9 score does not justify inventing four separate dimension weaknesses.

A suggested Q11 answer that keeps businesses in focus

The following version illustrates complete coverage. It is a new teaching example, not a rescored response or the report's generated improved answer.

A decline in commuting could help some businesses because they could spend less on office space. For example, a company with staff working from home might rent a smaller office and use the savings to buy better equipment. However, businesses near busy offices could lose customers. A café beside a train station, for instance, might sell fewer breakfasts and coffees if fewer workers travel into the city. So the change could lower costs for some companies while reducing sales for others. The effect would depend on the kind of business and how much it relies on commuters.

This version contains 97 words. Delivered across 45 seconds, that would be about 129 WPM. That is a timing calculation, not a measured recording or a guaranteed scoring pace.

Prompt requirementHow the example fulfills it
Positive effect on businessesLower office-space costs
Positive exampleA company rents a smaller office and buys equipment with the savings
Negative effect on businessesFewer customers and lower sales
Negative exampleA station café sells fewer breakfasts and coffees

The vocabulary is accessible. The improvement comes from answering the specified question and making each effect concrete.

What the rubric supports

The ETS Take an Interview scoring guide considers relevance, elaboration, speaking pace and pauses, intelligibility, and language control. Its higher-score descriptions combine a developed answer with clear, connected delivery. It does not prescribe a numerical WPM threshold or a mandatory word count.

That supports two practice priorities in this case: produce more connected speech, and use that speech to explain the required ideas. Simply speaking the same off-target answer faster would leave the business-effects question unanswered.

A focused TOEFL Speaking practice routine

  1. Identify the subject before answering. In Q11, say “businesses” to yourself. Then identify the required positive effect, negative effect, and examples. Keep those requirements in view during practice.
  2. Build one business effect at a time. Practise “Companies could save money because…” and add a concrete example. Then practise “Some local businesses could lose customers because…” with a different example.
  3. Connect short stretches of speech. Use Q8's existing ideas to practise “My commute takes ten minutes, so I arrive with enough energy to concentrate.” Aim for natural phrase boundaries instead of stopping after every few words.
  4. Record a fresh 45-second answer. Check coverage first, then listen for pauses and inspect pace and word count. As an initial exercise, try to move beyond the 35-to-39-word responses with relevant explanation. Any word-count target is a practice aid, not an ETS scoring rule.
  5. Try a different prompt. Use the same process on a new business or workplace question. A memorized commuting answer cannot show whether the skill transfers.

Keep repetition practice targeted as well. Review the exact wording of the weaker Listen and Repeat items, especially omitted phrases and substituted words. The 5.0 on Q6 shows that sentence length alone cannot explain every repetition result in this attempt.

Frequently asked questions

Why can someone score well in Listen and Repeat but lower in the Interview?

Listen and Repeat supplies the language to reproduce. The Interview requires the speaker to generate and develop relevant answers. This learner's results show stronger performance on the supplied-language task than on spontaneous responses.

Was slow speaking the only problem?

No. Output was limited throughout the Interview, but coverage changed too. Q8 and Q9 were complete. Q11 did not supply the required business effects and examples. Pace and task fulfillment need separate attention.

Does an answer need 100 words to get a high TOEFL Speaking score?

The ETS scoring guide does not set a 100-word requirement. Word count helps identify limited output, but relevance, development, delivery, intelligibility, and language use matter. Extra words that repeat an idea or miss the question do not solve the problem.

Does complete coverage mean a top score?

No. Q8 had complete coverage and scored 3.4/5. Answering the question is necessary, but the quality of delivery, development, and language still matters.

Are these typical problems for Indonesian speakers?

This is one Indonesian learner's attempt. It supports a diagnosis of her responses, not a general claim about Indonesian speakers or Indonesian-language influence.

What should this learner practise first?

Prioritize generating fuller, relevant Interview answers. Keep the prompt's subject in focus, explain each required point, and reduce disruptive pauses while maintaining clarity. Continue targeted repetition work on the sentences with wording errors.

Your next practice session needs a specific target

Take the free Chicago test at www.myspeakingscore.com. Review the response scores, transcripts, pace, and coverage. Then choose one problem to work on before recording again.

In this case, the clearest target is generating enough relevant speech to develop the answer the question actually requests.

Sources: The shared Chicago practice report, taken November 19, 2026, and the ETS Speaking Scoring Guide. The learner's nationality was supplied by John. The analysis uses displayed transcripts, metrics, and written feedback. Audio was not independently assessed for this article. The suggested Q11 answer and practice alternatives are new teaching examples.